I've got a vintage Ludwig kit from the 60s that's missing one of its bass drum hoops. The in-lay in the hoop that I've got is 1/2" wide.

I've seen some vintage Rogers and Slingerland hoops being offered and I was wondering whether any of you had used either of these brands on one of your vintage Ludwig kits.

I've been told that the Slingerland hoop should fit fine and that the width of the in-lay is, in fact, 1/2". However, I was also informed that the vintage Rogers hoop would not fit my Luddy kit.

Any and all knoweldge and/or personal experience regarding the interchangability of these vintage bass drum hoops would be greatly appreciated.