Only Admins can see this message.
Data Transition still in progress. Some functionality may be limited until the process is complete.
Processing Attachment, Gallery - 179.96660%

Value of Slingerland drum set Last viewed: 1 minute ago

Loading...

From tnsquint

Hemisemisemiquaver (great name by the way) you make a very good point and certainly one I had not considered. When I first started becoming interested in vintage drums I was surprised at the perceived value of Slingerland drums. I am the kind of guy that wants to understand why things are the way they are as opposed to just accepting it and therefore have a tendency to be pretty analytical about things. I, for one, would like to see Slingerland drums get the respect they deserve. In the meantime we can acquire some great drums at really cost-effective prices. Texan, your kit is immaculate and probably the finest example of a COW finish I have seen. It is highly unlikely to see that finish without some scuffs, scratches and dents, especially in larger sizes. To my eye the kit looks even better and more "professional" with the Pearl hardware as the Set-O-Matic hardware just seems so pedestrian to me. If you are bent on selling it, price it high and be patient. The worst that could happen is you would have to have two really great kits. Yay!!

tnsquint, thanks for the name comps and for understanding what I said. I have more to say and it's not directed at any one person. Consider it more of an editorial. If you'd like to read it in the voice of Andy Rooney feel free:

Some people here are very quick to just say "oh it's Slingerland". They don't get much like Gretsch or Rogers." Or "the market is down on Slingerlands". Some, like tnsquint and others, are more gracious and sympathetic to the issue and express heartfelt curiosity as to why it is this way. Either way, These same kind of comments have come up in other threads in VDF and at times these comments are carelessly thrown around based on what they've read in those previous threads. My point is if everybody keeps posting negative comments about the value of one of our great American drum companies it'll turn into a snowball effect. If everyone started saying the same about Rogers or Gretsch or Ludwig, which I know they won't and neither will I, wouldn't the same thing happen? Especially when it's said to those who come to this site for advice on their drums. There's a lot of traffic on this site and the more it is said the more it will be read and those who don't know how great these old Slingys are will not have an interest in buying them and our wonderful instruments, which are also investments, will become worthless. The company already killed itself once. Let's not kill it again.

Now, with that said, Texan forget what I said about $1500. Start at $2K. Your drums are in amazing condition and they deserve more.

1981 Slingerland Magnum 8pc Pewter Silk
1971 Slingerland Avante 60N Lavender Satin Flame
1976/7 Ludwig Vistalite 5pc Yellow
1980's Ludwig Rocker 5pc Black
2004 Gretsch Catalina Birch Caribbean Blue
1998 Noble & Cooley Alloy Classic 14X4.75
1922 Bower Snare
Posted on 12 years ago
#31
Posts: 6288 Threads: 375
Loading...

I'd think I'd sell the drums separately.

The snare might fetch $350.00 on it's own.

$250.00 apiece for the FTs

$150 apiece for the rides.

Maybe $150 for the bass.

This would fetch you $1300 pretty quickly.

I'd venture to say it would be a long time if ever that someone would offer $1300 for the whole set because of the bass drum mods....

Sorry, but for me the Pearl mounts kills it for a collector, so may as well break it up......

Just an opinion here...

It and a buck fifty will get you a non-Fair Trade cup 'o Joe....jess sayin

Kevin
Posted on 12 years ago
#32
Loading...

Hello All;

Thanks for all of your very thoughtful comments. I agree with the comments regarding talking down Slingerland. It becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. The people on this website constitute a great deal of expertise and buying and selling of vintage drums and as such, this forum acts as somewhat of a market, similar to a stock market.

As for the comments that Slingerland's marketing was the reason for it not being able to compete with Ludwig has some truth to it. However, Camco had almost no marketing, yet today those vintage drums command very high prices. I believe that the reason is that Camco is out of business and therefore no more will ever be built and that DW is the successor, if you will, to Camco and DW has a great reputation.

As far as breaking up the set, that won't happen, if for no other reason than the Pearl tom mounts and the corresponding hardware on the two toms. As far as the Pearl hardware being a negative to collectors, I would pose the question, would you not buy Ringo Star's Ludwig kit as collector with its Rogers tom mount? If your answer is that you would want that kit as a collector, then the issue of purity of a brand being sacrosanct as a collector goes out the window. I believe there are lots of reasons people collect things and each person is entitled to their own criteria, but I believe having something somewhat unique (Pearl tom mount on a Slingerland kit, especially when that mount was professionally installed and is superior in design to the Slingerland mount) is also a positive to some collectors.

With all of the above being said, I plan to put the set up for sale on this forum for $2,000 firm. I don't plan to sell it on eBay or Craigslist. I want this drum set to go to a good home where the new owner will appreciate it and keep the kit in great condition. I believe the people on this forum will do just that. The drum set will include all of the Pearl stands and pedals as well as a complete set of almost new Remo clear Ambassador and Pinstripe drum heads and a throne. I will also throw in some vintage Slingerland drum catalogs from the 60s and 70s. I will also try to find the Slingerland drum keys, which I saw somewhere in the house a few weeks ago, and the original sales receipt for the drums. If I can't sell the set for $2,000 it will go back in the closet for another decade.

Thanks again for every one of your thoughtful comments.

Posted on 12 years ago
#33
  • Share
  • Report
Action Another action Something else here