In general, the Rogers drums I've had provided the best sound to my ear. In particular, a set of blue onyx 22,13,16 and a matching PowerTone that I'd had in the mid-90's. I used to marvel at how good they sounded. The sound man at the Rat in Boston provided a live recording on a cassette tape one evening because he too was really digging the sound. I lost the tape in a move. Go figure. When he was looking them over, he did comment how many guys come in to play a gig with tired heads and he liked the fact that mine were fresh and considered it essential. I've found over the years that the heads have as much as anything to do with a good vibrant sound.
Similarly, when I listen to old live videos of Buddy Rich in action, none ever seems to come close to the WMP Rogers set with Dynasonic he used in the mid-60's when he was playing with Harry James. Similar sounds from that era of Louie Bellsons live recordings.
I did have a set of Leedy's in the 20,12,14 configuration from about '66 in red satin flame with a matching Shelly Manne snare. That is the closest anything else has come to giving me a totally pleasing sound. Love those COB hoops! Snare mechanism did leave a bit to be desired.
Like Mark (JRingo), I have to ask myself why I didn't keep those kits!!!!