In the right hands, digital recording will sound no different than analog. There is much focus on digital gear that recreates the sounds of the older methods. It sounds like you just had an idiot for a producer. Like it or not, digital is not going away. It's all in how you use it. That said, if I could afford it, I would go mostly analog myself.When stereo came along, mono purists were up in arms.Stephen
Stephen - Yes! Huge idiot! Wouldn't accept input from anybody other than the engineer who was hell-bent on cleaning up every note with his (then)new digital toys/filters. Every guy that worked those sessions (there were six of us,) complained about how drastically all their parts were altered. It wasn't just me. That little prique took one or two bars of the groove I was playing, and dropped it in/as a patch, anywhere he damn well chose. The repetition of the copies of the same few bars in what was a two-and-a-half minute piece is what made it sound fake/mechanical, like a machine. Not like a live drummer. I'm sure a lot of that 'scrub it clean' mentality was tied to the newness of the technology... playing with new toys. It was like; if the software came with a certain set of filters, they felt obligated to use them. Whether it made any aesthetic sense/contribution, or not. I'm sure they've outgrown a lot of that by now. I haven't been inside a recording studio in 15 years, glad to hear they are 'coming around' to a more musical approach to recording as opposed to a purely technical one. I miss that wall of sound. Bunch of guys interacting live, sounds bouncing off the walls, the band cooking.... nothing like it.
Here's a sample of it from the Master record producer himself, Phil Spector. Phil would pack a bunch of musicians into a studio and mic the room. Listen to how BIG and full the sound is. How 'alive' and immediate it sounds. I wish the sound quality on this clip was better, but it'll do to illustrate my point about a 'live' sound.
Crank it!
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqgtsai2aKY[/ame]
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzhbGaCwBzs[/ame]
John