Don't you think that's a little bit of sentimentality?
No disrespect, to older drums, I love my kents, ludwigs, I had a set of '70s Pearls and I have several vintage (I think) Gretsch snares, '60s, I have been searching for a great, affordable, Gretsch or Rogers kit. I love those drums and I love playing them. I gig with the ludwigs, jazz, and get great feedback from the other musicians and audience members about the sound. I have a real respect for what we probably all agree is vintage.
Banana bikes??? What about those big fat tire touring bikes of the '50s, what about those skinny tire, curled handlebar racing bikes of the later 70s, or the titanium mountian bikes of the 80s? It's purely subjective, each generation has it's sentimental attachments and insists that the next generation just will never understand. I hear my Dad talking about the cars, and music, and movies of the '40's and '50s and I appreciate some of that stuff, but he thinks Zeppelin and Floyd are crap! I think when we are all long gone, the next generations will decide what is vintage. I think to say that nothing made after a certain date will ever be vintage, well maybe that's true to you and I but we can't say what future drum guru's will decide.
I know guys who collect "vintage" macs, and macbooks. Are they really vintage? Who says?
I guess I originally asked the question "What makes it vintage?" because I've seen the term abused, like on ebay and craig's list. It sounds nicer than saying Old or used, so people use it to make a sale.
I agree that vintage is characterized by excellence, maturity, and enduring appeal, and maturity is really age, enduring appeal is subjective, excellence while less subjective is still in the eye, or ear of the beholder to some extent.
Banana bikes?
What about hot wheels, the original ones, like the '69 stingray, sure beats sitting in front of a screen playing Grand Theft Auto, but that's just my opinion.